Fibonacci Multiple Puzzle

Source: Mailed to me by Kushagra Singhal, Ex-IIT Kanpur, PhD Student at University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign


Prove that for any positive K and a natural number n, every (n*K)th number in the Fibonacci sequence is a multiple of the Kth number in the Fibonacci sequence.

More formally, for any natural number n, let F(n) denote Fibonacci number n. That is, F(0) = 0, F(1) = 1, and F(n+2) = F(n+1) + F(n). Prove that for any positive K and natural n, F(n*K) is a multiple of F(K).


  1. Lemma. F(n) = F(k+1).F(n-k) + F(k).F(n-k-1)
    = F(2).F(n-1) + F(1).F(n-2)
    = F(3).F(n-2) + F(2).F(n-3)
    = ...
    = F(k+1).F(n-k) + F(k).F(n-k-1)

    Now for proof of the main question, suppose F(k) divides F((n-1)k) [inductive hypothesis].
    From above lemma, we have,
    F(n.k) = F(k+1).F((n-1).k) + F(k).F((n-1)k - 1)
    Since F(k) divides F((n-1)k), F(k) divides F(n.k).

  2. Use the formula for F_n given here.

    Also, a-b divides a^n-b^n. Let a=Phi^k and b=phi^k. Observe that the factor (a^n-b^n)/(a-b) is an integer.

  3. We prove this using induction. Before that, we make a small observation about Fibonacci numbers

    For any positive integer k,
    F(k+2) = F(k+1) + F(k)
    F(k+3) = 2*F(k+1) + F(k)
    F(K+4) = 3*F(k+1) + 2*F(k)
    F(k+m) = F(m)*F(k+1) + F(m-1)*F(k)
    where m is a positive integer

    We need to prove that for a positive integers K and n, F(n*K) = c*F(K) where c is a positive integer.
    Setting K to be any positive integer, and applying induction on n,
    The base case is n = 1. F(K) = 1*F(K). Thus the base case holds.
    Assuming the statement is true for some n. F(n*K) = c*F(K)
    F((n+1)*K) = F(n*K+K) = F(K)*F(n*K+1) + F(K-1)*F(n*K)
    But F(n*K) = c*F(K).
    Thus F((n+1)*K) = F(K)*(F(n*K+1)+c*F(K-1)) = c'*F(K) where c' is a positive integer
    Thus the induction holds.

    The given statement is true for all positive integers K and n.

  4. Lemma:
    For 0 <= k < n:
    F(n) = F(k+1) * F(n-k) + F(k) * F(n-k-1)

    This can be proven by induction on k.
    base case k = 0:
    F(n) = 1 * F(n) + 0 * F(n-1)

    Since F(n-k) = F(n-k-1) + F(n-k-2), one can rearrange coefficients, so that
    F(n) = F(k+1) * F(n-k) + F(k) * F(n-k-1)
    F(n) = F(k+1) * (F(n-k-1) + F(n-k-2)) + F(k) * F(n-k-1)
    F(n) = (F(k+1) + F(k)) * F(n-k-1) + F(k+1) * F(n-k-2)
    F(n) = F(k+2) * F(n-k-1) + F(k+1) * F(n-k-2)

    To finish, use induction on n to show that F(n*K) is a multiple of F(K).
    base case n = 0:
    F(0) = 0 is a multiple of F(K)

    By the lemma,
    F((n+1)*K) = F(K+1) * F(n*K) + F(K) * F(n*K-1)
    and since both F(n*K) and F(K) are multiple of K, so is F((n+1)*K)

  5. Here is a brute force method:

    its well known that F(n)= [a^n-b^n]/sqrt (5) where a= (1+sqrt(5))/2 and b= (1-sqrt(5))/2.
    so its required to prove that [a^(n*k)-b^(n*k)]/(a^k-b^k) is a whole number.

    in fact a little algebra shows that above expression is a whole number for natural n and k ,and real numbers a and b , provided a+b and a*b are whole numbers.

    outline of proof:
    let x=a^k and y=b^k.
    prove by induction , that x^i+y^i is a whole number for any natural i.
    its clear that for natural i , (x*y)^i is also a whole number as a*b is a whole number.

    expression of interest = [x^n-y^n]/[x-y].
    =sigma (x^i)* y^(n-1-i), i = 0 to n-1.
    if n is even, the expression equals sigma (x*y)^i * [ (x^(n-1-2*i)+y^(n-1-2*i) ], i = 0 to (n-2)/2
    if n is odd , the expression equals (x*y)^((n-1)/2) +sigma (x*y)^i * [ (x^(n-1-2*i)+y^(n-1-2*i) ], i = 0 to (n-3)/2.

    hence proved as (x*y)^i and x^i+y^i are whole numbers for all natural numbers i.

  6. Assume that F(nK) is a multiple of F(K). We shall prove that F((n+1)K) is also a multiple of F(K).

    F(nK+2) = F(nK+1) + F(nK)
    F(nK+3) = F(nK+2) + F(nK+1) = 2F(nK+1) + F(nK)
    F(nK+4) = F(nK+3) + F(nK+2) = 3F(nK+1) + 2F(nK)
    F(nK+5) = F(nK+4) + F(nK+3) = 5F(nK+1) + 3F(nK)
    F(nK+6) = F(nK+5) + F(nK+4) = 8F(nK+1) + 5F(nK)
    F(nK+i) = F(i) F(nK+1) + F(i-1) F(nK)

    Thus, when i=K, we have F((n+1)K) = F(K) F(nK+1) + F(K-1) F(nK), which is a multiple of F(K) as both terms are multiples of F(K) (recall that F(nK) is a multiple of F(K)).

  7. F(n+1) = F(n-1)+F(n)
    F(n+2) = F(n-1)+2F(n)
    F(n+3)= 2F(n-1)+3F(n)
    F(n+k)=F(k)F(n-1)+F(k+1)F(n) -- 1
    so, F(2n) = F(n)F(n-1)+F(n+1)F(n) = t*F(n)
    assume F(nk) = L*F(n) ( since we proved F(2n) = t*F(n))
    F(n(k+1)) = F(nk+n)=F(n)F(nk-1)+F(n+1)(F(nk) = L*F(n))
    rhs is divisible by F(n)

  8. Any fibonacci number could be written as sum of any two (lower) value of fibonacci numbers. for example:

    f(10) = f(9) + f(8)
    = 2f(8) + f(7)
    = 3f(7) + 2f(6)
    and so on..

    So, if we split f(nk) it could be written as

    f(nk) = x1*f(k+1) + x2*f(k)

    These coefficients also follows fibonacci pattern. For example:

    f(10) = f(2)*f(10-1) + f(1)*f(10-2)
    = f(3)*f(10-2) + f(2)*f(10-3)
    = f(4)*f(10-3) + f(3)*f(10-4)
    and so on...

    therefore x1 will be equals to f((n-1)k)

    now the equation could be written as:

    f(nk) = f((n-1)k)*f(k+1) + x2*f(k)

    which could be re-written as

    f(nk) = [ f((n-1)k) ] *f(k+1) + x2*f(k)
    = [ x3*f(k+1) + x4*f(k) ] * f(k+1) + x2*f(k)
    = [ f((n-2)k)*f(k+1) + x4*f(k) ] * f(k+1) + x2*f(k)

    and so on...
    and the final equation would be like:

    f(nk) = f(k)*a1*f(k+1) + a2*f(k)
    = f(k) [ a1*f(k+1) + a2 ]

    and at one point the coefficient of f(k+1) will be a multiple of f(k).
    Hence every f(nk) has f(k) as its factor.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Asking a girl out

Coins Puzzle

Consecutive Heads